Skip to content

Project Review & Recommendations

Overall Assessment

The project demonstrates solid engineering practices with a well-structured codebase. The separation of concerns is clear, components are modular, and the state management approach is pragmatic.

Key Strengths

  1. Cart Implementation
  2. Clean separation between UI and state management
  3. Effective use of React Context for global state

  4. Smart persistence strategy with localStorage

  5. Checkout Flow

  6. Well-orchestrated process with clear state handling
  7. Good use of react-hook-form for form management
  8. Clear loading/error/success states

1. State Management Refinements

  • Currently exposes raw setCart function in CartProvider, which could lead to inconsistent state
  • Recommendation: Replace with specific action functions: 
    {
  addToCart: (product: Product) => void;
  removeFromCart: (productId: string) => void;
  updateQuantity: (productId: string, quantity: number) => void;
  clearCart: () => void;
}

2. Security Enhancements

  • Session tokens stored in localStorage are vulnerable to XSS
  • Consider implementing:
  • HttpOnly cookies for session management
  • CSRF protection for mutations
  • Rate limiting on checkout endpoints

3. Payment System Flexibility

  • Currently hardcoded to Cash on Delivery
  • Suggested improvements:
  • Abstract payment method selection
  • Implement payment gateway integration interface
  • Add support for multiple payment providers

4. Error Handling

  • Add comprehensive error boundaries
  • Implement retry logic for failed GraphQL operations
  • Add detailed error logging and monitoring
  • Consider implementing offline support/queue for cart operations

5. Performance Optimizations

  • Implement cart item quantity debouncing
  • Add product list virtualization for large catalogs
  • Consider implementing optimistic UI updates
  • Add prefetching for common user paths

6. Developer Experience

  • Add more comprehensive TypeScript types
  • Consider implementing Storybook for component development
  • Add unit tests for critical business logic
  • Implement automated accessibility testing

7. User Experience

  • Add toast notifications for cart operations
  • Implement better loading skeletons
  • Add offline support indicators
  • Improve form error messaging and validation feedback

Priority Recommendations

  1. High Priority
  2. Secure session management (move from localStorage to HttpOnly cookies)
  3. Implement specific cart action functions instead of exposing setCart

  4. Add comprehensive error handling

  5. Medium Priority

  6. Flexible payment gateway integration
  7. Performance optimizations

  8. Enhanced error feedback

  9. Nice to Have

  10. Developer experience improvements
  11. Additional UX enhancements
  12. Automated testing expansion